DOMANDA Msi B350M Mortar, Asus Prime B350M-A o Gigabyte GA-B350M-Gaming 3?

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Ciao ragazzi!

Semplicemente:
Qual è migliore secondo voi?
MSI B350M Mortar, Asus Prime B350M-A o Gigabyte GA-B350M-Gaming 3?

Confrontando le specifiche, sulla carta sembrerebbe avanti la Gigabyte, seguita dalla Asus e poi la MSI. Vorrei sapere però come si comportano davvero, dato che online si trovano:
- Alcune persone che consigliano Gigabyte, ma molte persone che hanno avuto problemi
- Poche persone che consigliano MSI, ma molti che si sono trovati alquanto bene
- Nessuno che parla di Asus

Grazie in anticipo!
 
Ultima modifica:

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
La migliore in quel segmento a me mi è parsa la b350 gaming della gigabyte. E fanno anche la versione m

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
Perché? Con la Asus mi sembra molto simile... Forse le tue impressioni sono collegate alla versione atx, bisognerebbe vedere se si comporta ugualmente anche la micro.
 

Carmine1989

Nuovo Utente
99
12
Perché? Con la Asus mi sembra molto simile... Forse le tue impressioni sono collegate alla versione atx, bisognerebbe vedere se si comporta ugualmente anche la micro.
Sisi infatti se vedi ho scritto che nel comparto la migliore mi sembra la gigabyte gaming... nemmeno la gaming 3...e penso sia simile la micro...pero non so...

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
 
  • Mi piace
Reazioni: MarcoTuccia

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Sisi infatti se vedi ho scritto che nel comparto la migliore mi sembra la gigabyte gaming... nemmeno la gaming 3...e penso sia simile la micro...pero non so...

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
Ok. Grazie per il feedback.
 
Ultima modifica:

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Nel frattempo riporto quanto ho trovato su Tom's Hardware UK, in favore della Gigabyte GA-AB350M-Gaming 3:

"Depends on how many ports/connections you need and your preferred features. Both the Asus and Gigabyte have:

Same type of chipset (B350, obviously).
Same 4x RAM slots at max. 64GB cap. and 2133MHz to 2666MHz speeds.
Same 6x SATA ports and 1x M.2 socket.
Same 3x Audio Jacks (Line In, Line Out and Mic In) at rear panel.
Same Audio Codec (Realtek ALC887) and LAN Controller (Realtek 8111)
If using AMD APU (not Ryzen CPU), sameVideo Outputs (1x HDMI v1.4, 1x DVI-D, and 1x VGA).
Same number of Internal USB Headers (1x USB 3.0 internal header and 2x USB 2.0 internal headers).
Almost same micro-ATX size board dimensions (244mm x 240mm for Asus vs 244mm x 244mm for Gigabyte).

What sets the above Asus and the Gigabyte motherboards apart are these differences in features/connectivity:

Asus has only 1x PCIe x16 slot | Gigabyte has 2x PCIe x16 slots (1x running at x16 + 1x running at x4).
Asus can only support a single GPU | Gigabytecan support two GPUs in CrossFire mode (not SLI).
Asus has 2x PCIe x1 slots | Gigabyte has only 1x PCIe x1 slot.
Asus has 2x PS/2 ports at the rear (dedicated for Keyboard and Mouse) | Gigabyte has only 1x PS/2 port (combo).
Asus has 6x USB rear ports (2x USB3.1 Type A + 4x USB3.0) | Gigabyte has 8x (same + 2x USB2.0).
Asus has 1x Serial (19-Pin COM) Port | Gigabyte has 2x.
Asus has no Parallel (25-Pin LPT) Port | Gigabyte has 1x.
Asus has a total of 2x Fan Headers (1x for CPU + 1x for Case) | Gigabyte has 3x (1x for CPU + 2x for Case).
Asus has 1x RGB LED Strip/LED Fan Header (12V/G/R/B) | Gigabyte has none.
Asus has no built-in Ambient LED Lighting Effects | Gigabyte has built-in Ambient LED Lighting (Red color only).
Asus is generally Black + Gray + Silver theme | Gigabyte is generally Black + Gray + Red theme.
Asus does not support Dual BIOS | Gigabytesupports Dual BIOS (exclusive feature).
Asus has only 2 out of its 6 SATA ports oriented 90-degree | Gigabyte has 4 out of its 6 SATA ports in 90-degree.
Asus has 2 of its SATA ports sharing lanes with the M.2 socket (whether in SATA-mode or PCIe-mode) which means using the M.2 socket will disable both SATA ports (SATA6G_5 and SATA6G_6) leaving you with only 4x SATA ports available | Gigabyte has 2 of its SATA ports sharing lanes with the M.2 socket (but only if in PCIe-mode; not in SATA-mode) which means using the M.2 socket in SATA-mode will only disable 1 SATA port (SATA3_3) leaving you with 5x SATA ports available, but using the M.2 socket in PCIe-mode (at x4 speeds) will disable 2 SATA ports (ASATA3_0 and ASATA3_1) leaving you with only 4x SATA ports available. If M.2 socket is used in PCIe-mode (at x2 speeds), all 6x SATA ports will still be available.

By the above differences, you can see clearly that the Gigabyte packs the most connectivity and features. If such additional connectivity and features are not a necessity to you, then the Asus will suffice. If you want those perks, then get the Gigabyte."
 

Carmine1989

Nuovo Utente
99
12
Nel frattempo riporto quanto ho trovato su Tom's Hardware UK, in favore della Gigabyte GA-AB350M-Gaming 3:

"Depends on how many ports/connections you need and your preferred features. Both the Asus and Gigabyte have:

Same type of chipset (B350, obviously).
Same 4x RAM slots at max. 64GB cap. and 2133MHz to 2666MHz speeds.
Same 6x SATA ports and 1x M.2 socket.
Same 3x Audio Jacks (Line In, Line Out and Mic In) at rear panel.
Same Audio Codec (Realtek ALC887) and LAN Controller (Realtek 8111)
If using AMD APU (not Ryzen CPU), sameVideo Outputs (1x HDMI v1.4, 1x DVI-D, and 1x VGA).
Same number of Internal USB Headers (1x USB 3.0 internal header and 2x USB 2.0 internal headers).
Almost same micro-ATX size board dimensions (244mm x 240mm for Asus vs 244mm x 244mm for Gigabyte).

What sets the above Asus and the Gigabyte motherboards apart are these differences in features/connectivity:

Asus has only 1x PCIe x16 slot | Gigabyte has 2x PCIe x16 slots (1x running at x16 + 1x running at x4).
Asus can only support a single GPU | Gigabytecan support two GPUs in CrossFire mode (not SLI).
Asus has 2x PCIe x1 slots | Gigabyte has only 1x PCIe x1 slot.
Asus has 2x PS/2 ports at the rear (dedicated for Keyboard and Mouse) | Gigabyte has only 1x PS/2 port (combo).
Asus has 6x USB rear ports (2x USB3.1 Type A + 4x USB3.0) | Gigabyte has 8x (same + 2x USB2.0).
Asus has 1x Serial (19-Pin COM) Port | Gigabyte has 2x.
Asus has no Parallel (25-Pin LPT) Port | Gigabyte has 1x.
Asus has a total of 2x Fan Headers (1x for CPU + 1x for Case) | Gigabyte has 3x (1x for CPU + 2x for Case).
Asus has 1x RGB LED Strip/LED Fan Header (12V/G/R/B) | Gigabyte has none.
Asus has no built-in Ambient LED Lighting Effects | Gigabyte has built-in Ambient LED Lighting (Red color only).
Asus is generally Black + Gray + Silver theme | Gigabyte is generally Black + Gray + Red theme.
Asus does not support Dual BIOS | Gigabytesupports Dual BIOS (exclusive feature).
Asus has only 2 out of its 6 SATA ports oriented 90-degree | Gigabyte has 4 out of its 6 SATA ports in 90-degree.
Asus has 2 of its SATA ports sharing lanes with the M.2 socket (whether in SATA-mode or PCIe-mode) which means using the M.2 socket will disable both SATA ports (SATA6G_5 and SATA6G_6) leaving you with only 4x SATA ports available | Gigabyte has 2 of its SATA ports sharing lanes with the M.2 socket (but only if in PCIe-mode; not in SATA-mode) which means using the M.2 socket in SATA-mode will only disable 1 SATA port (SATA3_3) leaving you with 5x SATA ports available, but using the M.2 socket in PCIe-mode (at x4 speeds) will disable 2 SATA ports (ASATA3_0 and ASATA3_1) leaving you with only 4x SATA ports available. If M.2 socket is used in PCIe-mode (at x2 speeds), all 6x SATA ports will still be available.

By the above differences, you can see clearly that the Gigabyte packs the most connectivity and features. If such additional connectivity and features are not a necessity to you, then the Asus will suffice. If you want those perks, then get the Gigabyte."
Che asus sarebbe? Perché la b350 plus (che sarebbe quella migliore da paragonare con la b350 gaming..non gamung3) ha 8 porte sul retro e nessuna striscia per led...comunque preferisco la gaming e non la gaming3... della b350m infatti ce solo la gaming di gigabyte

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
 

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Che asus sarebbe? Perché la b350 plus (che sarebbe quella migliore da paragonare con la b350 gaming..non gamung3) ha 8 porte sul retro e nessuna striscia per led...comunque preferisco la gaming e non la gaming3... della b350m infatti ce solo la gaming di gigabyte

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
Le schede di cui si parla sono tutte quelle in titolo. E mi interessano solo micro-atx, quindi non prendo in considerazione le atx.
 

Carmine1989

Nuovo Utente
99
12
Allora devi considerare la gigabyte b350m gaming....la gaming 3 nn esiste purtroppo micro

Inviato dal mio SM-G930F utilizzando Tapatalk
 

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Ragazzi il dubbio persiste. L'unico parametro che mi permette di fare una classifica delle tre è il prezzo, ma non posso di certo prenderlo in considerazione...
 

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Up. Nessuno che mi sa consigliare una delle tre?
 

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Up. Non ho fretta, ma rimango in attesa.
 

MarcoTuccia

Utente Attivo
889
150
CPU
Intel Pentium G4600
Dissipatore
Stock Intel
Scheda Madre
MSI B250M PRO-VD
HDD
Seagate Barracuda 7200rpm 64mb cache 1tb
RAM
Patriot Viper 2x4gb 3000mhz CL16
GPU
Zotac GeForce GTX 970 Dual Fan
Monitor
Samsung SyncMaster S22B150
PSU
Corsair CX550M
Case
Jonsbo C2
Periferiche
Cooler Master Devastator 2 kit
OS
Windows 10 64 bit
Up del giorno.
 

serassone

UTENTE LEGGENDARIO
Utente Èlite
29,197
8,578
CPU
Core i5 3570K
Dissipatore
Noctua NH-U9B SE2
Scheda Madre
Gigabyte GA-Z77X-UD3H
HDD
Crucial MX500 500 GB | Crucial MX500 1 TB | WD Blue 1 TB | 2 x WD Green 3 TB
RAM
2 x 8 GB DDR3 1866 Corsair Vengeance
GPU
nVidia GT 1030
Audio
VIA integrata
Monitor
Asus VW246H 24" 1920x1080
PSU
Enermax MODU87+ 500W
Case
CoolerMaster Stacker
OS
Windows 10 Pro x64
Up del giorno.
Il lungo post in inglese che hai citato, in pratica da' il consiglio che darei anch'io: guarda per bene a tutte le caratteristiche accessorie (compresa la MSI che ti interessa) e scegli quella che maggiormente si adatta alle tue esigenze. Le schede madri moderne offrono più o meno le stesse prestazioni, ormai gran parte dei componenti fondamentali (per esempio, il controller ram e il controller PCI Express per la grafica) sono contenuti all'interno del processore.
 
  • Mi piace
Reazioni: MarcoTuccia

Entra

oppure Accedi utilizzando
Discord Ufficiale Entra ora!

Discussioni Simili